Gloucestershire Green Party
  Home arrow Democracy and Community arrow Six Myths of Lords Reform
| Join | Donate | Contact Us | South West Green Party |
Advertisement
Main Menu
Home
Meetings
News
Elections
Local Parties
Reports
Campaigns
Links
National
Green Party
Young Greens
Green World
Green Issues
Green Economics
Climate Change
Peak Oil
Peace, Justice and Security
Food We Can Trust
Transport
Education, Health and Housing
Democracy and Community
Animal Rights
Lucky Dip
Six Myths of Lords Reform Print E-mail
The Elect the Lords campaign have identified six myths that they believe are unnecessarily confusing the public debate over House of Lords reform.

These are arguments employed by opponents of House of Lords reform which are presented as fact despite having no factual basis. The six myths identified are:

•     The House of Lords is more "independent" than the House of Commons because it is appointed;
•     Elections would give party leaders more control over the second chamber;
•     Electoral systems are "majoritarian";
•     There is no "consensus" on Lords reform;
•     Electing the second chamber would challenge the primacy of the Commons;
•     The House of Lords is institutionally biased against Labour governments.

Commenting, National Co-ordinator of the Elect the Lords Campaign Peter Facey said: "It is absurd that political patronage forms such a central part of the British constitution in the 21st century, and many of the arguments employed to defend it are equally absurd."

 

Read more from:
http://electthelords.org.uk/pages/myths.html